Subsurface and Buried Watering

What are the disadvantages of subsurface drip irrigation?

The main disadvantages of subsurface drip irrigation, including cost, hidden leaks, root intrusion, rodents and germination problems, plus how to reduce each.

On this page
  1. The Short Answer
  2. The Main Disadvantages, Explained
  3. What Are the Disadvantages of Micro Irrigation in General?
  4. When Subsurface Drip Is Still Worth It
  5. Alternatives If the Drawbacks Rule It Out

The Short Answer

The main disadvantages of subsurface drip irrigation are:

  1. Higher upfront cost and installation effort than surface drip or a basic sprinkler setup.
  2. Problems are hidden. Leaks, clogs and dry spots are hard to see until plants show stress.
  3. Root intrusion, where roots grow into emitters looking for water.
  4. Soil suction, where soil is drawn into emitters as lines drain after shutting off.
  5. Rodent and digging damage to tubing you can’t see.
  6. Poor germination for surface-sown seeds and shallow transplants.
  7. Limited sideways spread in sandy soils, which can leave dry strips between lines.
  8. Salt build-up near the surface in dry climates or with salty water.
  9. High dependence on filtration and water quality.
  10. Repairs and changes are disruptive, because you have to dig to reach the line.

None of these rules subsurface drip out. Most can be greatly reduced with good design, but they’re worth understanding before you bury anything. The sections below explain each one and what you can do about it.

The Main Disadvantages, Explained

1. Cost and Installation Effort

A buried system uses the same core parts as surface drip, plus a few extras: flush headers, air/vacuum relief valves, often higher-grade dripline with root protection, and valve boxes. Trenching or inserting lines takes labour or equipment, especially under an existing lawn.

How to reduce it: Install subsurface drip when you’re already building a new bed or lawn and the soil is open. Save it for areas where its advantages matter most, such as narrow strips, slopes or windy sites, rather than every part of the garden.

2. You Can’t See Problems

With surface drip, you can walk the lines and see a split tube or a dead emitter. Underground, the first sign of trouble is often a soggy patch, a dry patch, or plants that look stressed. By then the problem may have been going on for some time.

How to reduce it: Install a pressure gauge or test port and note the normal reading, so a change stands out. A flow meter can flag leaks. Pop-up operation indicators confirm the zone is pressurised. Check soil moisture directly with a probe instead of judging by the surface.

3. Root Intrusion

Roots naturally grow toward moisture, and an emitter is a constant moist spot. If the soil around a buried line dries out between cycles, roots can grow into the emitter outlets and block them.

How to reduce it: Use dripline designed for burial with root-intrusion protection. Some products use copper or root-inhibiting compounds in the emitter. Avoid long stretches where the system sits completely unused during the growing season. Follow the manufacturer’s guidance on scheduling and maintenance.

4. Soil Suction Into Emitters

When a buried zone turns off, water draining out of the lines can create a slight vacuum. That vacuum can pull muddy water and fine soil back in through the emitters, which gradually clogs them.

How to reduce it: Install an air/vacuum relief valve at the system’s highest point so air, not soil, fills the line as it drains. Dripline with built-in check valves can also help by keeping the line full. Our guide to subsurface drip components explains where these parts go.

5. Rodents and Digging

Gophers, voles and other burrowing animals sometimes chew buried tubing. People cause damage too: digging planting holes, driving in stakes, installing edging, or core-aerating a lawn.

How to reduce it: Ask local installers what works against rodents in your area. Keep an accurate map of where your lines run. Check your line depth against aerator tine depth before aerating. Our article on how deep to bury subsurface drip line covers why depth matters for avoiding damage.

6. Seeds and New Plantings Don’t Get Enough Water

Surface-sown seeds need the top layer of soil kept moist, and buried dripline is designed to keep the surface fairly dry. New sod and small transplants with shallow roots can also struggle until their roots reach the wetted zone.

How to reduce it: Plan on temporary surface watering, such as a hose, a hose-end sprinkler or temporary surface drip, while seeds germinate and plants establish. We discuss this for turf in subsurface drip irrigation for lawns.

7. Limited Sideways Spread in Sandy Soil

In clay and loam, water from an emitter spreads outward a good distance. In sand it moves mostly downward. If lines are spaced too far apart for the soil, strips between them stay dry, which is very visible in a lawn.

How to reduce it: Space lines more closely in sandy soil, follow the manufacturer’s spacing tables, and consider a test area before committing to the whole yard.

8. Salt Build-Up

Water moves outward and upward from a buried line, and as it evaporates near the surface it leaves dissolved salts behind. In arid regions or with salty irrigation water, salts can concentrate in the soil above and between lines. Rain usually flushes them back down, but where rainfall is scarce they can accumulate.

How to reduce it: Where salinity is a concern, occasional deep watering or surface leaching may be needed. Test your water if you suspect it’s salty, and get local advice.

9. Dependence on Filtration and Water Quality

Emitter passages are tiny. Sediment, algae, iron and other minerals can clog them, and a buried clog is much harder to fix than a surface one.

How to reduce it: Use the filter mesh the dripline maker specifies, clean it regularly, and flush the laterals through the flush header. Water from wells, ponds or rain tanks may need extra filtration or treatment.

10. Repairs and Changes Are Disruptive

Fixing a leak or moving a line means digging. Redesigning a bed, adding a tree or changing a lawn’s shape can mean rerouting buried tubing.

How to reduce it: Plan the layout carefully before installing. Leave access points at headers and flush valves, and keep the map up to date.

What Are the Disadvantages of Micro Irrigation in General?

Micro irrigation covers drip, subsurface drip and micro-sprays. Its general drawbacks overlap with the list above:

  • Clogging from sediment, minerals and organic growth, which makes filtration essential.
  • Regular maintenance: filter cleaning, flushing and checking for leaks.
  • Damage to surface tubing from sunlight, foot traffic, tools and animals.
  • Limited wetted area. Some plants may root mainly where water is applied.
  • No frost protection and no cooling effect on foliage, unlike overhead sprinklers.
  • Planning matters. Poorly designed systems with runs that are too long or pressure that’s wrong can water unevenly.

When Subsurface Drip Is Still Worth It

Despite these drawbacks, subsurface drip is often a good choice for:

  • Narrow strips and odd shapes where sprinklers overspray onto paving, walls or windows.
  • Windy, hot or dry sites where evaporation and drift waste a lot of water.
  • Permanent plantings such as established shrub beds, perennials and lawns, where you won’t be digging often.
  • New installations, where the soil is already open and lines can be placed accurately.
  • Gardeners who want an invisible system and are comfortable checking soil moisture instead of watching sprinklers run.

If those match your situation, the drawbacks are usually manageable. Our overview of the advantages of drip irrigation gives the other side of the comparison.

Alternatives If the Drawbacks Rule It Out

The complete guide to subsurface and buried watering

Subsurface Drip Irrigation: Components and Installation
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →